“I’m a Better Mother Since I Left My Child”: Examining Schwartz’s Argument

1. Introduction

In the article “I’m a Better Mother Since I left My Child,” Daylle Deanna Schwartz admits that in some situations, it is better for children to live with their single fathers. This is a very controversial claim, and one that is sure to generate a lot of public debate. In this essay, I will examine Schwartz’s argument, and provide my own thoughts on the matter.

2. The Argument

Schwartz begins her argument by recounting her own experience as a divorced mother. She states that she felt like she was “failing” as a mother, and that she was constantly being judged by others. After some soul-searching, she came to the conclusion that it would be best for her daughter if she lived with her father. She argues that this decision was met with criticism from both her friends and family members, who all believed that she was “abandoning” her daughter.

3. The Support

Schwartz provides several reasons to support her claim. First, she argues that mothers are often portrayed as selfless martyrs in our society, and that this over-idealization can put a lot of pressure on them. Second, she states that mothers are not always able to give their children the attention they need, due to work and other obligations. Third, she claims that in some cases, it is actually better for children to be raised by their fathers. Fourth, she argues that mothers who divorce their husbands often face a lot of stigma and criticism from society.

4. The Counterargument

Critics of Schwartz’s argument might argue that mothers are not always selfless martyrs, and that they are capable of giving their children the attention they need. They might also argue that in some cases, it is actually better for children to be raised by their mothers. Finally, they might claim that mothers who divorce their husbands do not always face stigma and criticism from society.

5. The Rebuttal

In response to these criticisms, Schwartz could argue that while mothers are not always selfless martyrs, they are often under a lot of pressure to be perfect parents. She could also argue that while mothers are capable of giving their children the attention they need, they often have other obligations which prevent them from doing so. Finally, she could claim that while mothers who divorce their husbands do not always face stigma and criticism from society, they often do face such judgement when they make the decision to leave their children with their fathers.

6. Conclusion

In conclusion, Schwartz’s argument that in some situations, it is better for children to live with their single fathers is a valid one. While her claims are sure to generate some public debate, I believe that she makes a strong case for her position.

FAQ

Leaving her child has made Schwartz a better mother because she is now able to focus on her own happiness and wellbeing, which in turn makes her a more patient and present parent.

Schwartz feels she is now a better mother than she was when she lived with her child because she is no longer bogged down by the day-to-day stresses of parenting, and can instead focus on enjoying quality time with her child and being fully present during that time.

After she left her child, Schwartz's parenting style changed from one that was focused on meeting the needs of her child to one that was focused on providing a happy and healthy environment for both herself and her child.

This new parenting style has had a positive impact on Schwartz's relationship with her child, as it has allowed them to connect on a deeper level and enjoy each other's company more fully.

Some people might disagree with Schwartz's decision to leave her child because they believe that mothers should always put their children first, regardless of their own happiness or wellbeing. However, others may see Schwartz's decision as an act of self-care that ultimately benefits both mother and child.

I think more mothers should consider leaving their children if it would make them happier and healthier parents, as long as they are able to maintain a strong and healthy relationship with their child.